A few days ago, I was walking down one of the central streets of Moldavanka. There are many shops there, a trolleybus stop nearby. In short, Stepovaya, a far from deserted street. On the pedestrian sidewalk, closer to the roadway, stood an old baby carriage filled with some junk. And under it, curled up in a ball, slept a person. People walked by, paying no attention to him.
Judging by his clothes, it became clear that this person was homeless. At one point, it even seemed that the man showed no signs of life. I wanted to get my phone to call an ambulance, but he stirred and began to slowly get up, then sat down near his stroller on the asphalt, lowered his head low, and seemed to fall asleep again in a sitting position. Only long hair and a gray beard were visible from under the hood of his jacket, thrown over his head. People continued to walk by…
“He’s fine!”?
In childhood, doctors diagnosed Igor with one of the diagnoses on the list of so-called mental illnesses – mental disorders of the nervous system. The fate of people with such problems is not easy. But as long as his mother was alive, his life was more or less good. Igor was always at home, not in the hospital. His mother did everything she could to ensure prosperity, comfort, and all the necessary medications prescribed by his doctor.
But his mother passed away. Igor Alimovich, who was already over forty at the time, was left alone. No close relatives, no friends. However, he inherited two small apartments from his mother. One of them is a two-room apartment on Kosmonavtov Street, in a cooperative 5-story building, the second is on Marshala Babajanyana Street, in the so-called old building.
But after some time, he ended up in a psychiatric hospital. The reason was the alleged sharp deterioration of his mental state, expressed in aggression towards one of the neighbors. Soon, the Malinovsky district administration of Odesa appointed a guardian for him. And for 7 years now (since 2013), Igor Alimovich Aslanovich has been in the Medical Center for Mental Health at Vorobyova Street, 9.
“Lyudmila Lisovskaya, Igor’s mother, was not just a neighbor to me, we were friends,” says Larisa Sklyar. “I remember Igor from childhood. He never showed any aggression, at least when spoken to calmly, and was quite adequate. And on the day he was forcibly taken to the hospital, those who later signed the prepared report or statement about his alleged social danger, in essence, probably provoked his outburst of anger themselves and called an ambulance.”
In addition, she said that the apartment on Babajanyana Street, over the 7 years that Igor Aslanovich has been in the hospital, has today turned into a non-residential premises, more resembling a utility room. But utility bills in Aslanovich’s name come regularly, and the amounts on them are considerable, including debts for gas and electricity.
“A neighbor whose apartment is located next to the 21st (this is the number of Aslanovich’s apartment) bricked up two windows himself because they bothered him, demolished the extension that belonged to Igor, and occupied the freed-up territory,” says Larisa Sklyar.
It should be noted that Larisa Valentinovna is the only one who truly did not remain indifferent to the fate of her neighbor. After some time, she visited him in the hospital. He looked unkempt and hungry. What the hospital staff told her then about his behavior as a patient did not fit the image of the person she had known for many years. Sklyar was also struck by Igor’s appearance. Despite the fact that Aslanovich was officially assigned a guardian, who, in accordance with the law, took on the responsibility of caring for his ward and the right to dispose of all his property, including two apartments, Igor did not even have the most basic necessities – warm underwear, a sweater, a tracksuit.
Larisa Valentinovna repeatedly appealed to the guardianship and trusteeship commission of the Malinovsky district administration to find out who was appointed guardian and why this person was not fulfilling his duties conscientiously. She also wrote appeals to the head of the district administration, Evgeny Omelchuk, and even had an appointment with him. But she always received formal answers: “employees of the district administration constantly monitor the performance of guardians’ duties.” To the question about Igor Aslanovich’s health, which she regularly asked the Malinovsky administration employees by phone, she was always answered the same thing: “He is fine!”. This is despite the fact that the person had been in a psychiatric hospital for many years, where the regime is largely similar to prison.
She also appealed to a city council deputy representing the interests of their electoral district, and to the head of the Malinovsky police department in Odesa. But there too, she received purely formal answers.
Larisa Valentinovna’s active stance gradually began to cause irritation among some people whose interests did not align with her attitude towards Aslanovich’s fate. Communication with representatives of the guardianship authorities ended in verbal altercations. “You are not doing the right thing,” district administration employees told her.
Relations also deteriorated with Aslanovich’s closest neighbor, Kostya, who, according to Larisa Sklyar, inexplicably had Igor Aslanovich’s passport. Twice, neighbors attacked her with their fists when she brought up the topic of compensating the person for what had been taken from him.
On October 6, after another such conversation, Kostya, according to Larisa, hit her several times in the face, after which she lost consciousness for a while. And if not for the intervention of other people, it could have ended for her not only with a broken eyebrow and a huge hematoma on her face, but also more tragically.
Now Larisa Valentinovna’s statement about the attack on her and the infliction of bodily harm is in the Malinovsky police department, where, apparently, they are in no hurry to investigate the case.
“Guardians don’t want to take their wards!”
*Reference. Guardianship is a form of state care for incapacitated citizens. It is established, controlled, and terminated by guardianship and trusteeship authorities, which are structural units in district administrations, executive committees of city and village councils.*
“We are saving his life,” replied the doctor, who recently and temporarily replaced Igor Aslanovich’s previous attending physician, to my questions about why Igor is not allowed home, at least periodically, and how serious his condition is.
Later, in a conversation with the chief physician of the Odesa Regional Center for Mental Health, Anatoly Voloshchuk, as he carefully reviewed the patient’s medical history, it turned out that at the beginning of the year, Aslanovich underwent an examination for referral to a specialized boarding school. However, the examinations were not completed for some reason, as was the entire processing. As a result, Igor remained in the hospital.
This fact indicates that his health condition at that time was probably satisfactory, as the process of transferring him from the hospital to the boarding school had begun. But why to a boarding school, and not home, where a guardian could care for him?
“Today we are facing a serious problem,” the chief physician comments on the situation. “We have people who, due to their health condition, could have been home long ago, but their guardians do not take them. Moreover, as soon as we ask them to take their wards and care for them at home (most of the patients had their own housing when they were admitted to our center), complaints immediately begin. They write to all authorities about us and bring activists to the center’s walls, accusing us of allegedly not wanting to treat people.”
According to staff, representatives of the prosecutor’s office systematically visit their center. They conduct their “rounds” of the wards, where they ask patients one question: who among them believes they are here without reason? If someone states this, their medical history is transferred to the prosecutor’s office, where the documents are carefully studied.
The problem is becoming not so much medical as social. In the context of the second stage of medical reform, which began in April of this year and has also affected psychiatric hospitals in terms of significant funding cuts, it has become practically impossible to maintain “social beds.” A huge number of people may soon be discharged from the hospital simply onto the street, as they often have nowhere to go.
*Reference. The Civil Code of Ukraine states that a guardian is a capable person appointed by a court or guardianship authorities to care for a ward. Guardianship is established over incapacitated persons, as well as over partially incapacitated persons – trusteeship.*
“When was the last time you visited Aslanovich?” we asked an employee of the ward where Igor is currently located, at the moment when Larisa Sklyar was handing her gifts for her neighbor.
“About a month ago. His nephew brought the medicine, the one prescribed by the doctor when he got sick.”
“And do they periodically bring him any food, fruits, hygiene products, necessary items?”
“No, only the medicine was brought,” was the answer.
*Reference: Guardian’s duties: to care for, treat the ward, provide him with necessary living conditions, take measures to protect the civil rights and interests of the ward. The rules of guardianship and trusteeship state that the guardian must live with the ward and can be registered at his residential premises during the period of his duties. At the same time, the income of an incapacitated person is transferred to the disposal of his guardian. The latter is obliged to spend it on the maintenance of the ward.*
Deprivation of legal capacity as civil death?
“Successful people” do not like to talk about psychiatric hospitals. Those who have been there as patients are stigmatized for the rest of their lives. “They are crazy,” say people who consider themselves normal about them.
And few people think that a significant portion of psychiatric hospital patients and residents of specialized boarding schools are no more ill than any other person considered adequate. After all, people are often sent to psychiatric hospitals by their “caring” relatives or guardians appointed by guardianship councils. People are declared incapacitated posthumously and often without valid reasons, without delving into their real mental and physical condition, or the situation around them. And this means that an adult person is equated to a young child, deprived of any rights, including the right to property. Often, as a result, the loss of everything – housing, friends, relatives, and simply human living conditions.
The Civil Code states that this status is acquired by people who “due to a mental disorder cannot understand the meaning of their actions.” A person deprived of legal capacity cannot participate in elections of any level, get married, dispose of their money, or open a bank account.
In November 2017, a law was adopted and then enacted in Ukraine, № 2205-VIII, which provides for changes in legislation on the provision of psychiatric care. The norm on the sterilization of an incapacitated person with medical indications with the consent of his guardian was removed from the Civil Code. In addition, the possibility of terminating compulsory psychiatric treatment is provided if the court satisfies the corresponding application of the person or his legal representative. The law transfers a number of requests/consents to written form – previously, oral or “conscious” ones were sufficient. This applied to the use of diagnostic and treatment methods that pose an increased risk to human health.
Reference. Psychiatric examination, outpatient psychiatric care are provided to a person from 14 years of age at their request or with their conscious written consent; up to 14 years of age – at the request or with the consent of their parents; to an incapacitated person – by their legal representative.
The first thing that needs to be done is to change the guardianship system, which opens up opportunities for various abuses, lawyers and human rights defenders believe today. People are now being deprived of all rights, and this is unacceptable. In Ukraine, more than 40,000 people in psychiatric and neurological boarding schools live in, to put it mildly, inhumane conditions.
The entire system needs to be changed, but for this, legislation needs to be changed, specialized boarding houses need to be created where lonely people with mental disabilities could live, receiving necessary help, but not losing their right to human dignity. And building and maintaining such boarding houses could be funded, in part, by the funds that in many cases are obtained by unscrupulous guardians or simply fraudsters.
But until this happens, we will increasingly see people on the sidewalk, thrown out of their apartments and homes onto the sidelines of life. We will encounter the monstrous mercenary cruelty of some and the equally disgusting indifference of others, who lock a person in a hospital simply to take away his apartment or property. We will consider that people like Sklyar are doing “the wrong thing.” And her neighbor Kostya – a practical and respectable person.
But in that case, everyone should understand that any of us, regardless of our material or social status today – if we continue to live by such rules – tomorrow could find ourselves in the place of Aslanovich or that unknown person, living out his days on the street under a rusty baby carriage.











