So, last week, the official start was given to the land reform that has been talked about so much lately. On Friday, a draft law describing the procedure for selling agricultural land, which has been subject to a moratorium for almost twenty years, appeared on the Ministry of Economy’s website.
The document has been put up for public discussion. Moreover, the draft law still needs to be approved by the Cabinet of Ministers, and then it will be submitted to parliament. However, as the methodology of the new government’s work shows, parliament, in the person of the mono-majority, does not allow for significant delays in adopting laws. And this means that the opening of the land market will take place on the scheduled date – October 1, 2020.
Therefore, we need to prepare for it. First of all, mentally. After all, on the one hand, it is clear that agricultural land – since Ukraine professes a market economy – should be a commodity that can be freely sold, bought, and pledged. But another thing is also clear. Such a responsible step – to put up for sale the main Ukrainian wealth: black soil – must be done with maximum caution and compliance with all necessary legal criteria and requirements.
Experts explain the desire to open the land market, in part, by the increased pressure from Western creditors, particularly the International Monetary Fund. After all, the lifting of the land moratorium has always been part of the IMF’s demands for providing Ukraine with money. When the country refrained from another loan, for example, in 2010-2013, the fund’s pressure could be ignored. Then, under President Poroshenko, certain movements began, but they were mostly formal in nature, in order to convince the IMF to give money.
Well, Volodymyr Zelensky’s team decided to act, as they say, from the get-go. Western “friends” are rushing, as Ukraine is again preparing to borrow from the International Monetary Fund. But feeding promises of lifting the moratorium will no longer work. It is evident that the issue has been put to creditors strictly, as the classics say: money versus chairs. It is no coincidence that the World Bank is taking an active part in drafting the bill on opening the agricultural land market. And foreign experts and advisors will also monitor how the law is implemented.
At the same time, opponents of the proposed land reform clearly point out to the country’s leadership the basic requirements, without which the moratorium cannot be lifted under any circumstances. Speaking of legal aspects, a law on the circulation of agricultural land must be adopted first. Otherwise, the black soil market will go underground. It is also proposed to introduce a minimum land value with mandatory linkage to the real market value.
The land inventory procedure is far from complete. According to specialists, only 30 percent of land plots in the State Cadastre have been identified and received cadastral numbers. Courts across the country are flooded with cases related to establishing land boundaries, determining their owners, and inheritance rights.
In such a situation, declaring the land market open means condemning the country to a new round of judicial bacchanalia and organizational chaos. It is enough to say that it was precisely because of the inadequacy of the public cadastral map that land raiding has flourished in Ukraine in recent years. Crop seizures directly from the fields are also explained by the fact that a particular plot suddenly turns out to have different owners – due to discrepancies in the Cadastre.
The abolition of the land moratorium is absolutely not in solidarity with the decentralization reform, as it involves transferring state land to the ownership of united territorial communities.
True, the president tried to allay fears about the upcoming land reform. Thus, even before the presidential elections, the speaker of Zelensky’s headquarters stated that it was necessary to “…create a normal legal framework, protect the interests of the state, protect the interests of the owner, the interests of the investor, and then open the market.” And last week, the head of state clarified that “…in the model that we will propose with the government, only Ukrainian citizens and Ukrainian companies will be able to buy or sell land.” Volodymyr Zelensky called the “scaremongering” about foreigners allegedly taking black soil by the wagonload nonsense.
However, as a quick analysis of the published draft law, which is not a separate legislative act but a package of amendments to existing legislation, shows, many pitfalls of the land market opening procedure have not disappeared.
For example, the authorities promise that only “Ukrainian citizens and Ukrainian companies” will have access to black soil. The draft law does prohibit non-residents, i.e., foreign companies, from claiming to buy agricultural land. But nothing is said about foreign citizens. Therefore, specialists say, a foreigner with money can easily acquire a Ukrainian company that has already acquired land. And become its legal owner. And this is just one example of how the aforementioned norm of the draft law can be circumvented.
Critics of the idea of opening the land market were outraged by another proposed innovation. The Land Code has a reservation that farmers and persons with specialized education have the pre-emptive right to acquire agricultural land. It is also specified that the land must be used for its intended purpose. There are no such reservations in the draft law. The right to acquire agricultural land is to be given to everyone who wishes. Such openness can lead to very bad consequences. Where is the guarantee that the land will not lie idle, and individual “owners” will not destroy the black soil through unskilled farming? According to some specialists, if the aforementioned restrictions are not reinstated, speculative capital will flood the land market, the main goal of which will be to change the intended purpose of land plots.
Many questions immediately arose regarding the mechanism for farmers to buy land. The draft law provides for state compensation for loan interest rates. But, firstly, the money, as financiers have already calculated, will only be enough for “selected” farms. And what to do with the rest, the draft law does not specify. Secondly, banks are still very reluctant to work with small farmers, and interest rates on loans remain sky-high. In such a situation, those who have access to cheap financial resources will benefit. And these are, first and foremost, large agricultural companies and… foreigners.
And most importantly – were the people asked, starting the land reform? After all, agricultural land is perhaps the most valuable asset that the state of Ukraine possesses. However, no one from the new government is talking about a nationwide referendum yet…











