mon, 23 nov --:--:--
USD 0 0
EUR 0 0
А9582.64 ДТ93.04
+17° Одеса

Ми — ваша газета

This has been talked about in Ukraine for a long time: political scientists, economists, public administration analysts. And recently in Odesa, at a “round table” meeting organized by the Institute of Market Problems and Economic-Ecological Research of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine (a detailed report on the event was published in the issue of March 7), the President of the Ukrainian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs, Anatoliy Kinakh, asked a question that is, as they say, very relevant.

Namely, what aid plan are our foreign friends-helpers currently implementing in our country? The Marshall Plan? Or the Morgenthau Plan?

Many of us have heard of the Marshall Plan. This was a program to aid Europe after World War II, authored by U.S. Secretary of State George Marshall. The plan’s implementation began in April 1948. The recipients of aid were 17 European states, including West Germany. The main points of the plan were the restoration of the European economy with subsequent industrial modernization, the removal of trade barriers, the expulsion of communists from positions of power, and the development of democratic institutions. The program lasted for almost twenty years, and Japan and several East Asian countries also received aid under it.

It is clear that the Marshall Plan had many critics. In particular, it was noted that the Americans used the program for trade expansion, supplying Europe not with means of production and raw materials, but with finished products and food. Many restrictions on trade were also imposed on countries participating in the Marshall Plan. For example, the French were forbidden to buy cheap Polish coal – only American coal, which was twice as expensive. And so on.

However, this is not the most important thing. The goal was achieved – the European economy recovered from the consequences of the war in just 20 years. The foundation for economic and political globalization was laid. The influence of communist ideas in Western Europe sharply weakened, and the standard of living for all segments of the population noticeably increased. Finally, the middle class was restored and strengthened – the basis for political stability and sustainable development of any capitalist state.

Are we observing anything similar in our country? Let’s set aside the political component of the Marshall Plan. Are there any fundamental changes in the national economy as a result of aid from foreign friends? Do they bring positive changes to the standard of living of all, I emphasize, all categories of the population? The questions are, alas, rhetorical and sad…

So what is happening then? And here, specialists recalled and started talking about the Morgenthau Plan, which provided for post-war transformation, not of all of Europe, but only of West Germany. These were kind of preventive economic measures to deprive the country that unleashed the most terrible war in human history of the opportunity to repeat it all again. The program was proposed in September 1944 by U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Morgenthau.
And here’s what he came up with. The liquidation of heavy industry, the dismantling of production equipment, the destruction of a unified banking system, deforestation, a strict tax policy, and much more. And most importantly – the transformation of West Germany into an agrarian raw material country.
Does this remind you of anything? Are there no analogies? It turns out that in order to deprive a country of any economic ambitions and make it a docile political appendage, one must deprive it of its industry and banking sector, making agriculture the dominant sector.
True, the Morgenthau Plan had to be abandoned soon. Because after all the above measures, the standard of living in post-war West Germany sharply declined, and famine began. The program was canceled.
“Wikipedia” provides an explanation of the reasons for the failure of the Morgenthau Plan, voiced by former U.S. President Herbert Hoover, who visited Germany immediately after the war. Here’s what he said: “It is an illusion that an annexed New Germany can be turned into an agrarian state. This is unattainable unless we destroy or remove 25 million people from it.”
That is, to transform a country from industrial to agrarian, a large population is not needed. On the contrary, extra mouths are a hindrance. If the population is halved – by any means – then it will be a different story.
Does this remind you of anything?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Загрузка…

Мітки

Наша галерея

Вечірня Одеса