sun, 22 nov --:--:--
USD 0 0
EUR 0 0
А9582.64 ДТ93.04
+17° Одеса

Ми — ваша газета

A horse and a trembling doe…

…tried to harness the project’s cart with new licensing conditions for employment intermediary activities for citizens abroad by members of the public council under the Ministry of Social Policy and the Federation of Maritime Unions of Ukraine, who gathered in Odessa last week for a “round table”.

Representatives of the aforementioned central executive body, Oleg Solomakha and Oleg Dyachuk, as well as the head of the department for mediation and employment control of the State Employment Service, Alexander Antonyuk, participated in the meeting.

The event was a logical continuation of a working meeting organized by the State Inspectorate of Ukraine for Maritime and River Transport Safety for public discussion of the regulatory legal acts that Ukraine needs to adopt if our country decides to join the ILO Convention 2006 “On Maritime Labour”, which is called the Consolidated Convention for convenience. “Vechernaya Odessa” reported on this event on March 24.

However, if a month ago the discussion was somewhat theoretical, as it was unclear when the Law No. 222-V111 “On Licensing of Certain Types of Economic Activities” adopted by the Verkhovna Rada would come into force, according to which mediation in employment abroad remained a licensed type of economic activity, and the licensing authority, as before, is the Ministry of Social Policy, then now the discussion has moved into a practical plane. The basic parameters have become known. The law comes into force on June 28. By this date, the Ministry of Social Policy is obliged to develop, with the involvement of the interested public, the relevant Licensing Conditions, which will then be submitted for approval to the Cabinet of Ministers.

True, the “round table” left more questions than answers. It turned out that the Consolidated Convention, on a number of points, enters into categorical contradiction with the current Ukrainian legislation. This implies that, at least until Ukraine joins this international treaty, no legal innovations that meet the spirit of the convention can be introduced.

However, those who advocate for early ratification are not satisfied with this. Therefore, attempts are being made to harness the horse and the trembling doe into one cart by proposing to transfer the provisions of the convention into the draft new Licensing Conditions. It became clear that such an undertaking was doomed to failure almost immediately, as soon as the participants of the “round table” began to discuss the topic. In general, the discussion dragged on for almost three hours, and no consensus was reached.

The Consolidated Convention, on a number of points, enters into categorical contradiction with the current Ukrainian legislation. This implies that, at least until Ukraine joins this international treaty, no legal innovations that meet the spirit of the convention can be introduced.

Which is not surprising. If the ILO Convention 2006 “On Maritime Labour” provides for the separation of seafarers into a separate category of labor migrants, then the Law of Ukraine No. 222-V111 “On Licensing of Certain Types of Economic Activities” enshrines the indivisibility of the unified market of intermediary services into separate segments based on professional characteristics. Simply put, Ukrainian legislation considers all citizens seeking work abroad to be equal in their rights. The Consolidated Convention, however, considers seafarers to be “more equal” than others. For what reason is not explained.

The second basic principle of economic activity for mediation in employment of citizens abroad is the paid nature of the services provided. However, the Consolidated Convention requires that so-called “employment and recruitment services” be created in each country that joins it, which must provide services to clients free of charge.

Again, it is unclear why seafarers – with all due respect to representatives of this profession – should be granted such a privilege. And on the other hand, how will it look? An intermediary enterprise, based on its license, can provide employment services to representatives of any profession. For example, a “flag-of-convenience” seafarer, a welder looking for work at a foreign shipbuilding plant, a programmer, and, say, a medic come to an agency. Then, intermediary services will be free for the maritime specialist, but for others – for money? Is this normal?

The provision on the free nature of intermediary services for seafarers did not arise by chance. The fact is that a number of shipowners, when hiring crews, pay an agency fee. Therefore, it is argued, the seafarer should be exempted from paying for intermediary services, as the employer does it for him. But here’s the nuance. Not all shipowners pay an agency fee. And there are fewer and fewer of them every year, as the crisis in the global shipping industry continues.

According to the Ministry of Social Policy, there are 260 intermediary enterprises operating in Odessa today. Given the specifics of our city, almost all of them are involved with seafarers. At the same time, only two dozen of them receive agency fees from foreign employers. Most shipowners prefer to save money. Why pay Ukrainian intermediaries agency fees for seafarers when they can recruit crews from Southeast Asian countries that do not impose any financial requirements on the employer?

Therefore, if a norm on the free nature of intermediary services exclusively for maritime professionals is “inserted” into the licensing conditions, the market for employing Ukrainian seafarers on “convenient” flag vessels will simply collapse. After all, those intermediaries who can afford not to charge clients today, relying solely on agency fees from foreign shipowners, will be able to provide jobs abroad for, at most, twenty percent of the total number of applicants.

On the other hand, the requirement for free services will lead to the closure of most intermediary enterprises, as the officially received money from clients is their only source of existence. As a result, the budget will lose taxes paid by intermediaries. Employees of intermediary enterprises will increase the already large army of the unemployed. The state will have to incur expenses for the employment of these specialists.

More than twenty higher and secondary maritime educational institutions, which today train personnel exclusively for work with foreign shipowners, will be left without work. Many training and certification centers for crews, numerous courses will cease to operate. Specialized medical centers involved in the medical examination of seafarers going on voyages will close. The volume of work for the diploma and passport departments of maritime ports will sharply decrease, as there will be very few people wishing to obtain a “seafarer’s identity document.”

Finally, most importantly, the inflow of foreign currency into the country in the form of wages of labor migrants will stop. Ukraine, which today desperately needs resources to maintain the exchange rate of the hryvnia, will lose a reliable source of domestic investment due to the collapse of the intermediary system.

In general, if somehow the supporters of immediate ratification of the Consolidated Convention manage to push through a norm on free intermediary services for seafarers into Ukrainian legislation, large maritime agencies will gain an undeniable advantage in the competitive struggle in the employment market. But this will be the only winner from the aforementioned legislative innovation. There will be many more losers. First of all, it is the Ukrainian seafarer himself, whose choice of intermediary will be significantly limited by the norm on free intermediary services. Well, and China, the Philippines, India will say “thank you,” as they will gladly occupy the vacated niche in the global market for maritime labor.

Mediation in employment abroad, as a type of economic activity, involves providing a service for which the intermediary has the right to charge a fee. In particular, the paid nature is provided for by Article 43 of the Constitution of Ukraine, Article 38 of the Law “On Employment of the Population,” the Commercial Code of Ukraine (paragraph 2 of part 1, paragraph 2 of Article 3, paragraph 4 of part 1 of Article 44), as well as the currently effective Licensing Conditions, approved by order of the Ministry of Labor and Social Policy No. 272 of 09/06/2010 (paragraph 5.3 of Article 5 and paragraph 7.1.5 of Article 7).

This is why the participants of the round table meeting got stuck. They really want to adapt the new Licensing Conditions to the standards of the Consolidated Convention. But how to do it if the norms and provisions of the international treaty contradict Ukrainian legislation? And on the other hand, is it even necessary to do it?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Загрузка…

Мітки

Наша галерея

Вечірня Одеса