The issues discussed by citizens on the “hotline” of “VO” on October 13th prompt a conversation about their own civic engagement.
This, it must be said, was demonstrated by the friends and acquaintances of Elena Viktorovna Vavilovа. To bring the “voice of the people” to the “responsible persons,” Elena Viktorovna turned to the newspaper. About 40 people from her circle participated in a lively discussion of the event! They discussed the laying of the Alley of Stars, which took place during the celebration of the city’s 220th anniversary.
Why this particular “star selection”? By what criteria is the selection made? Should this “star” simply be born in Odesa? Like, for example, Anna Akhmatova, who by chance appeared in the world here and then had no connection to the city? Or should a “star” be born and educated here, like, for example, Emil Gilels? Or live their life in their hometown? And not only artists have brought glory to the city, notes the reader. What about artists? Kiriyak Kostandi himself! And the mayor Grigory Marazli? And the journalist Boris Derevyanko? And musicians? Architects? Sailors?!
Why are the inscriptions on the pavement stars in English? Will the undertaking turn into a pathetic imitation, worries the Odesa cultural public. Their attempt to find the concept of the Odesa Alley of Stars on the Internet yielded no results (mine either). Will superficiality and subjective taste prevail in this project? Who are the consultants?
The director of the Department of Culture and Tourism of the Odesa City Council, Tatyana Markova, announced a plan to replenish the Alley of Stars on each city’s birthday. The first laying was planned for ten stars, but six were laid, apparently due to available funds. As they say, we shall see. The reader’s questions are for the Department of Culture and Tourism to note…
Taisiya Igorevna Pazina is a first-group disabled person, a participant in the Great Patriotic War. She lives at 74a Mechnikov Street. A year ago, on September 12, a social worker took the documentation for the water meter verification to Taisiya Igorevna’s apartment: veterans with disabilities had their meters verified free of charge. No one from the service company came to the house, and they answer calls with: “Wait for your turn.” They are now charging not by the meter, which is much more expensive.
I spoke by phone with Elena Petrovna Kitayskaya, director of the Department of Labor and Social Policy of the Odesa City Council. She took note of the reader’s name and promised to “prod” the social service to be more concerned about the needs of the elderly person. But at the same time, she informed that free water meter verification for veterans is not a law, but a city program approved annually. Budgetary funds of the city are allocated for it.
Vera Leontievna Shumilina (151/5 Dobrovolsky Ave.) hopes to reach a consensus with Roman Alexandrovich Goryachev, director of JKS “Severny,” through the newspaper, because she claims to have already been to his reception. In a telephone conversation with me, Roman Alexandrovich said that if the residents have problems, they should write an application. However, the problem was discussed at a general meeting of residents with the participation of JKS management in August: it was promised to replace the old cold water pipes in the basement.
V. L. Shumilina highly praises the work of Vitaly Nikolaevich Denisov, head of the JKS section: a competent professional, an efficient manager. The issue, as usual, comes down to a lack of funds at JKS. What threatened house 151/5 with trouble in the basement has been sealed and patched, and no leaks are expected, Denisov assured; the urgent agenda includes hot water supply communications in two other houses.
“But since promises have already been made,” insist the residents, “we would like them to replace the pipes in our house as well, while providing urgent assistance to other houses.”
I would like to bring readers up to speed on the mentioned “European standards.” We talk a lot about condominiums: it is beneficial for residents to organize associations of co-owners of apartment buildings and take control of payments, knowing exactly what costs what.
Here’s what lawyer and human rights activist Tatyana Montyan (laureate of the 2012 legal award “For Outstanding Professional Achievements”) said on this matter at a meeting with the public on September 6 in Sumy. A legal absurdity has taken root in our country: double ownership of housing. Apartments belong to the residents, but the building… belongs to the territorial community in the person of the city council. This vicious practice was introduced by the former mayor of Kyiv, Omelchenko, by decision No. 208 of December 27, 2001 – with the aim of “squeezing out” auxiliary premises in buildings, which residents could collectively manage. The precedent spread throughout the country…
In reality, from the moment 75% of the housing in a building is privatized, it automatically becomes the joint property of the residents of all apartments. This was formulated by the Supreme Commercial Court of Ukraine when considering a lawsuit concerning a building in Kyiv on Mezhyhirska Street, 5, where Montyan acted as a lawyer. The building is an integral property complex. And only the fact that the apartment owners did not bother to formalize their rights to the non-apartment space allowed the city authorities to include the buildings in the “community’s property.” Methods for calculating how many meters outside the apartment belong to each owner exist in the country, says Tatyana Montyan. But “no one wants to deal with it.”
If a developer plans non-residential premises in a future building for sale, they are obliged to include this condition in the project from the outset and pay the city an investment component.
The lawyer concludes: Article 10 of the Law on Privatization; Part 2 of Article 382 of the Civil Code of Ukraine; decisions of the Constitutional Court of March 2, 2004, and November 9, 2011 – this is the normative basis according to which everything located in the building beyond the doors of your privatized apartments is your joint property, the residents. And no title documents are needed to formalize it. Simply put, there is no need to organize any “condominiums.”
Do you know what follows from this? That neither the state, nor the city, nor JKS owes you anything. JKS is a service provider, and you, the owners, are the customers. For your money.
…I specifically studied European standards in Spain. What we call “condominiums” is called “comunidad” there, and it is widespread. A general meeting of a microdistrict (about a dozen houses). An elected council. An elected chairman. Every apartment owner in the microdistrict must serve a year as chairman. The position is public, and no one is paid for it. Each building has its own council and chairman; this position must also be held for a year by every apartment owner. At general meetings, reports are heard, and urgent needs are addressed. The council hires, with funds from the residents, an accountant, a concierge-manager, who is responsible for repairs and landscaping, and cleaners.
The land on which the buildings stand is owned by the apartment owners, proportional to the apartment’s square footage. The apartment owner pays an annual communal tax for it. For example, if you have a 104-square-meter apartment, you pay 500 euros per year.
Of course, their salaries and pensions are not of our size. But Spain is not the richest country in Europe either. And we want “European standards.” So, are we ready for them?
“The problem is that our people still haven’t realized themselves as joint responsible owners of integral property complexes. The apartment is mine, but the building belongs to the city or the housing maintenance office,” notes Tatyana Montyan…
Next Monday, October 27, Tatyana Stepanovna Zhakova, head of the information department, will be on duty on the “hotline” of “Vecherney Odesy” at 64-99-13 from 10:00 AM to 12:00 PM.











