Reminder: On September 19, a boy beat a girl at Secondary School No. 59. Concussion, bruises. The fifth-grader spent eight days in the hospital, and no one visited her. The guardian grandmother was outraged. Many media outlets reported on the conflict.
On October 11, a press conference was held regarding this incident, where it was announced that the Commissioner of the President of Ukraine for Children’s Rights, Yuriy Pavlenko, is taking personal control of the case of the beating in the Odesa school. According to him, negotiations were held with the Ministry of Education regarding the training of school teachers to respond correctly to such cases.
The editorial office of “Vechernaya Odessa” (and other media outlets as well) received a statement signed by 36 members of the staff of specialized school No. 59 of the Olympic reserve:
“The teaching staff of OSSH No. 59 is outraged by the appearance of unverified and biased materials about the school in the media. The skirmish between fifth-grade students was presented as a brutal beating. The circumstances of the conflict were not objectively presented: on September 19, Anastasia Belous (a judoka) provoked David Allahverdiev by insulting him and kicking him, and in response, he struck her in the face. As a result, the girl bit her lip. The class teacher, Zh. B. Kasyanova, immediately resolved the conflict. After that, the girl, accompanied by her brother, went to music school in normal condition. The next day, September 20, the girl attended classes, was prepared for lessons, and felt normal. From the middle of the nature studies lesson, her grandmother took her for a medical examination.
When school representatives were attacked by the media, the teaching staff could not give interviews because a commission from the education department was working at the school at that time, and all comments had to be documented. However, materials were broadcast and published in the press with distortions of facts, escalation of the situation, and baseless accusations against the school. It gives the impression that all this hype is commissioned for the selfish purposes of citizen T. F. Belous.
The teaching staff, which creates all the necessary conditions for the education and upbringing of student-athletes – champions of Ukraine, Europe, and the world, is outraged by the position of the media, which distort and exaggerate facts, posting them on the internet instead of professionally helping to resolve the conflict. We ask for an objective investigation of this situation and a response to our appeal.”
A commission of specialists from the city education department and the district (Primorsky) education department, headed by I. A. Krainova, was created to investigate the incident. Last week, the commission summarized its findings. This is the subject of our conversation with the chairperson, whose opinion is presented in the headline.
— Irina Alexandrovna, what goal did the commission set for itself?
— The main task is to determine what measures the teaching staff and school administration took to prevent child abuse. That is, we checked the legality of the administration’s actions in accordance with official instructions.
— Are there “standard” recommendations for incidents like this?
— There is an approved procedure for considering appeals regarding child abuse, as well as regulations for investigating accidents that occur during the educational process. The normative documents specify everything that the school should have done. Unfortunately, not everything was done. An order from the education department has been prepared, and the school principal will receive an administrative penalty upon his return from the hospital. As for other staff members, this issue will be decided by the district education department.
— What specific shortcomings do you see in the work of school No. 59?
— The issue should not be focused solely on this school. Unfortunately, similar incidents happen from time to time in many educational institutions. School No. 59 had not had such an incident for a long time. The teachers, apparently, did not expect anything like this. But in such a situation, teacher professionalism should have prevailed. This case should be extrapolated to all educational institutions. The main shortcoming is that insufficient attention was paid to educational work to prevent child abuse or abuse among children. Moreover, this attention should not be in the form of one-off fragmented events like talks and lectures, but in a system of measures. The class teacher, psychologist, and social pedagogue of the school must work in close contact. In doing so, various city psychological and pedagogical centers, child welfare services, and juvenile crime police should be involved. Many schools have a council for the prevention of offenses, but it often operates formally.
— Are there any plans at the city education department level to assist in organizing educational work in this direction, in uniting the efforts of “interested” officials?
— The city information and methodological center is preparing several seminars on the general topic “Conflict Situation” for teachers. Lectures have also been prepared for parents. And, first and foremost, activities for children have been planned. During any school inspection, we will analyze educational work plans, paying special attention to preventing cruelty in relationships between children. Sociological research shows that schoolchildren are most afraid of aggression from their peers. The pain threshold towards other people has shifted for today’s adolescents… However, this is a topic for another conversation.
I. A. Krainova reported that psychologists from the city methodological center spoke with the participants of the conflict. The school psychologist and social pedagogue attended classes in the fifth grade for several days, and a pedagogical council was held. Nastya, after missing a month of classes, started attending school. David was initially transferred to the sixth grade (there is no second fifth grade in school No. 59), but was quickly returned. The children are communicating with each other.











