On November 17, the Verkhovna Rada adopted a bill on the election of people’s deputies. It was presented by the Provisional Ad Hoc Commission (PAHC), which included representatives of both the parliamentary majority and the opposition. The bill provides for raising the threshold for political parties to 5%, abolishes the participation of blocs in elections, and introduces a mixed electoral system (50/50). Politicians, experts, and journalists are now discussing this event. There are many questions. And we will return to them more than once.
Interestingly, just a day earlier, on November 16, the opposition insisted on radically different conditions for electoral legislation. Thus, a member of the PAHC for developing the law, a BYuT deputy Serhiy Podhorny, claimed that his faction would insist on reducing the percentage of “majoritarians” from 50 to 30, lowering the threshold to 4%, and ensuring the participation of blocs in elections. But the very next day, Mr. Podhorny argued that the adopted law was “a victory for the opposition.” “We did everything possible to ensure that the elections scheduled for 2012 were democratic and transparent,” he stated.
Of the deputies from the “BYuT-Batkivshchyna” faction, 66 deputies voted for the bill, 13 did not vote, 25 were not present in the meeting hall at the time of the law’s adoption, and three abstained.
BYuT deputies who voted for the bill emphasize that its new version provides optimal protection against falsifications.
The adoption of the new Law on Elections to the Verkhovna Rada contributes to the creation of the most democratic model of society in Ukraine. This opinion was expressed in a conversation with a correspondent of “Timer” by the first deputy head of the Odesa regional party organization of BYuT, chairman of the BYuT faction in the regional council, Serhiy Veselov.
According to him, the introduction of a 5% threshold and the ban on the participation of political blocs in elections contribute to this.
“Such a system leads to the creation of the most democratic model of society, in which there are strong parties, and there should not be 192 of them, as in Ukraine, but 3-5 parties that should compete with each other in their programs and methods of their implementation, and people should live peacefully, not run to the barricades. As for the abolition of participation in elections by blocs, this is a European practice, and a party must demonstrate its program to its voters, and blocs have not led to anything good – these are constant unnecessary disputes and ambitions, blocs do not lead to consolidation,” Serhiy Veselov is confident.
The head of the regional BYuT faction called the proportional election system, where 50% of people’s deputies are elected by party lists, and 50% compete for a deputy seat in majoritarian districts, the most acceptable for Ukraine.
“For Ukraine, a proportional election system with open lists would be the most acceptable. Yesterday, a law was adopted, in which the option proposed by the Party of Regions, after certain amendments and refinements, was adopted with the support of the BYuT and Our Ukraine–People’s Self-Defense factions in the Verkhovna Rada,” said Serhiy Veselov.
As for the amendments made to the bill by the working group, he preferred to rely on the opinion of the BYuT political leadership on this issue.
“A compromise has been found in resolving many issues from previous elections, judging by what our leaders Mykola Tomenko and Serhiy Podhorny said, all remarks, including those of the BYuT faction, have been included in the amendments considered by the working group, which allow for the avoidance of unfair elections,” says the politician.
“The new election law will lead to the structuring of the Ukrainian political scene, but one should not overestimate the significance of the next elections,” believes political expert Ruslan Bortnik, whose commentary is posted on the website “Korrespondent.net.”
He believes that “the next parliamentary elections should be analyzed from the perspective of preparation for the presidential elections and a very likely next attempt at constitutional reform.” Most likely, these elections “will only determine the starting positions of political players in a more serious struggle for power in preparation for changes to the Constitution of Ukraine and the presidential elections in 2015,” Bortnik believes.
“As for the norms of the bill, it is obvious that elections under its rules will lead to political conservation. Moreover, this conservation can be with a plus sign. After all, for 20 years of independence, practically all politicians and political forces of the entire spectrum have been in power in Ukraine – the quality of power has not changed much from this. And political musical chairs do not always have a positive impact on the situation in the country,” believes Ruslan Bortnik.
“The return of the majoritarian component of elections carries the threat of the use of administrative resources, and our country is not unique in this regard. But even the local elections of 2010, based on the results in Western Ukraine, showed a significant limitation of influence and an overestimation of this tool.”
“Raising the threshold will allow to cut off insufficiently structurally developed or radical parties, as happened in the 2002 elections, which were held under a similar system, for example, with the Winter Generation Team (2.02%), the Green Party (1.3%), or the Natalia Vitrenko Bloc (3.22%).
At the same time, it will contribute to the creation of a stable parliamentary majority. And the ban on the participation of political blocs in elections will strengthen the processes of structuring the Ukrainian political scene, the tendency to unite around 200 small parties in Ukraine.”
Speaking about the majoritarian system, another political scientist, an expert at “Liga.net,” noted that the next parliament will be more difficult to control from Bankova. “Because it is easier to keep one large faction in check than several deputy groups that will appear in the Rada as a result of the mixed electoral system.”
“Our Ukrainians” emphasize that the introduction of a high 5% electoral threshold for parties is aimed at preventing new political forces from entering parliament and qualitatively renewing the government. This is an outright disregard for the position of more than 50% of Ukrainians who do not wish to vote for large parties that have been repeatedly represented in parliament today, according to a statement quoted by UNIAN.











