Viktor Savelyevich Bakhnev considers his apartment “unlucky.” And, probably, he has reasons to think so. Judge for yourself: four years ago, his neighbors on the upper floor had a fire. During the firefighting, water got into Bakhnev’s apartment and into the premises of other residents. Then his home was flooded by neighbors several more times.
Viktor Savelyevich is unable to carry out repairs himself – his pension doesn’t allow it, he lacks the skills, and his health is no longer what it used to be for such work. He appealed to the mayor’s office for help, and in May 2018, the Primorsky district administration provided him with financial assistance for housing repairs.
Housing and Communal Services “Fontansky” refused to repair V. Bakhnev’s apartment, so he had to look for a construction and repair organization licensed to carry out such work, as Viktor Savelyevich had to provide documentary proof of how the money was spent. While he was looking, his kitchen, due to a pipe clogged by neighbors, was flooded with sewage, so a plumber was urgently needed. Just then, an advertisement appeared on the entrance door, in which a plumber and, by coincidence, an electrician named Yuri offered his services, promising pensioners a discount.
“The plumber came on the evening of July 26, 2018,” V. S. Bakhnev recounts in a letter to the editor. “When discussing the contract, I told Yuri about the financial assistance I had received in the presence of a neighbor and set the condition that he could only start work after providing me with receipts for consumables and an estimate of the work cost. We agreed to meet in two days. I gave him a thousand hryvnias as an advance for the purchase of necessary materials. However, the next day, the plumber unexpectedly came to me without receipts and an estimate. And, ignoring my objections, he began work without authorization. I tried to stop him several times, explaining that I needed receipts and an estimate for reporting to the district administration, but in vain. Yuri solemnly promised that he would definitely provide these financial documents. I believed his words. When, after some time, I went into the kitchen, Yuri suddenly dropped the unfinished work and, in a rude manner, in a raised voice, demanded immediate payment of 9 thousand hryvnias. I tried to reason with him, but he forcibly pushed me out of the kitchen, pinned me against the wall, and started shouting: ‘Give me the money!’ He also threatened me with retribution. Remembering his words that he was a former drug addict who had completed a full course of treatment, and being in shock, I gave the plumber the amount he named. Having taken my money in the total amount of 10 thousand hryvnias, Yuri left without finishing the work. I ran to my neighbor and told him what had happened…”
On the neighbor’s advice, V. Bakhnev contacted the Primorsky police department, and soon he was informed that the materials had been sent to the Shevchenkivske police department “for further consideration and decision-making in accordance with the law.”
Naively, he thought that the police would immediately start looking for the plumber who robbed him, summon him for questioning, etc. As it turned out, the pensioner’s statement was not even entered into the Unified Register of Pre-trial Investigations, although the law prescribes to do so within 24 hours and inform the applicant. This was done only a month later, on September 12, 2018, after the Primorsky court, by its ruling, forced the entry of information about the committed offense into the ERPI. True, Viktor Savelyevich was surprised that Yuri the plumber’s actions were qualified as intentional minor bodily harm, while he, in essence, committed robbery. And this is a completely different article… Later, in a letter to the Prosecutor General’s Office, V. Bakhnev himself explains this circumstance: the “minor” article determines the investigator’s attitude to the proceedings (“Imagine, he hit him in the face, we don’t punish for a slap”).
How events unfolded further is clear from V. Bakhnev’s correspondence with the police leadership.
In November, Viktor Savelyevich received a response from the investigative department of the Shevchenkivske Police Department: “Pre-trial investigation is underway.” How it is “underway” is evident from a letter from the Odesa Local Prosecutor’s Office No. 3, which checked V. Bakhnev’s statement. The check established that “the pre-trial investigation has acquired the character of procrastination, not all investigative actions have been carried out to establish the circumstances of the criminal offense.”
At the same time, the prosecutor’s office instructs the investigator of the investigative department of the Shevchenkivske Police Department: to intensify the investigation, draw up a plan for investigative measures, properly formalize the materials of the criminal proceedings, interrogate the person indicated in Bakhnev’s statement, interrogate witnesses, establish documents confirming that Bakhnev had a certain amount of money, etc.
So, what’s the result? Is the investigator so inexperienced that he doesn’t even know what to do and needs a hint? Or maybe a first-year student who doesn’t yet know all the procedural subtleties is working in this position?
The prosecutor’s office points out to the leadership of the investigative department that since the entry of information into the ERPI, the investigation has not been conducted properly, not a single investigative action has been carried out, and no final decision has been made. “Take under personal control,” demanded the higher authorities.
Another month passed. In December, investigator D. Filipchuk of the Shevchenkivske Police Department instructed the operational unit to carry out investigative actions: to establish Yuri K.’s residential address, interrogate neighbors as witnesses, and clarify the circumstances of the incident.
January of the current year arrived. V. Bakhnev again complains to the Primorsky police department about the inaction of the investigation and receives another response: “The circumstances you are complaining about occurred in the territory served by the Shevchenkivske Police Department, so contact them…”
In March of this year, another response came from the local prosecutor’s office: “The investigation is ongoing. You have the right to appeal to the court with a complaint about the investigator’s actions…”
Following this “advice,” V. Bakhnev filed a complaint with the Primorsky court, in which he asks the court to oblige the responsible persons of the Shevchenkivske Police Department to carry out investigative actions on his statement. On July 26, the court recognized that the investigation had not carried out the procedural actions it was obliged to carry out within the period specified by the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and granted Viktor Savelyevich’s application.
From the entire correspondence, it is clear that no one – neither the prosecutor’s office, nor the leadership of the Primorsky Police, nor the investigative department of the Shevchenkivske Police Department – is properly dealing with V. Bakhnev’s case. And the investigator is not subject to higher authorities, despite the “stern” demand to conduct a “comprehensive, full, and impartial investigation.” Or maybe it’s difficult to find plumber Yura? No, his advertisements (with a phone number) offering services appear quite often in the microdistrict, and even on the entrance door of the building where Bakhnev lives. For a whole year, the police have not bothered to start a full-fledged investigation. And note, in none of the police leadership’s letters is there a word about holding investigators (and several have changed over the year) accountable for inaction.
…The other day, V. Bakhnev called the editorial office again. He said that, not waiting for any reaction to the court’s ruling, he wrote a statement to the regional investigative department. And he received a response: “Your statement has been sent to the Shevchenkivske police department…”











