An upcoming hearing is scheduled for today, June 26, at the appellate commercial court of Odesa region, where a case is being heard in which the regional prosecutor’s office is trying to prevent the implementation of a criminal scheme to “divert” communal property into private hands.
Details on how the Odesa City Council and the Department of Communal Property decided to “gift” elite real estate to business structures were covered in the issues of “Vechernaya Odesa” for April 24, May 13 and 22, and June 7 of this year. The newspaper also reported that when the case was heard in the first court instance, Judge Yu. Shchavinskaya saw nothing reprehensible in the “auction of unprecedented generosity” by the former city authorities. Therefore, the prosecutor’s office filed an appeal.
It is noteworthy that the case has gained significant public resonance. It turned out that Odesa residents are no longer willing to tolerate the fact that their present and future are shamelessly plundered by corrupt officials and shrewd entrepreneurs who know how to “get their way.” A fresh batch of reader responses received on “Vechorka’s” internet page is the best confirmation of this.
Lawyers Alexander Nikolaevich, Ilya Solomonovich, Viktor Pavlovich:
“Analyzing the court case about the embezzlement of city property, we, three veterans of the Odesa bar, with a total legal experience of over 100 years, have decided to respond as specialists not only in the field of law but also as professionals in the sphere of justice.
Previously, before the collapse of the Soviet Union, such a judicial “marathon” organized for the benefit of fraudsters and to consolidate the schemes of the city authorities, in order to ultimately steal more than twenty valuable city properties in the center of Odesa, was unthinkable in the Ukrainian Republic, and in Odesa in particular.
Firstly, during the Soviet era, city leaders and deputies, having committed the described criminal acts, would have immediately gone to the prosecutor’s office for questioning, and would have been immediately removed from their positions and deputy mandates.
Secondly, Judge Yulia Shchavinskaya would have ceased to work as a judge. And she would also have gone to the prosecutor’s office for questioning, and then to court. But not to her Odesa colleagues, but to another region of Ukraine.
It is very appropriate to recall the fate of the former judge of the Ilyichevsky District People’s Court of Odesa, Skuldytsky, who in the 80s was “imprisoned” for a trivial act of abuse of power and a petty bribe.
What Judge Yu. Shchavinskaya has done cannot be compared to the compositions of crimes for which people were simply put in the dock before. And were tried! And therefore, judges were not allowed to not only break the law but also to support crooks, even if they held the status of city and deputy representatives.
We earnestly request our respected editorial office to promptly and vividly cover this court case not only in the Odesa courts but also in its further stages in the cassation instances, in Kyiv, where not everything is clean and impeccable either. We are well aware of this. And we know those who carry tribute there.
We also remember from our young years of judicial career Lyudmila Boyko, as a very cautious and quite submissive to her superiors. That is why she deliberated with her colleagues behind closed doors for a long time on June 5. And in this regard, we ask the authors, legally literate journalists Rozovaykin and Suslov:
Publish who previously headed the Odesa commercial courts of the first and second instances, what was their style and methods of work, and how did they manage to excessively enrich themselves on “blind Themis”? How many bankruptcy decisions did they push through, and how did they bankrupt state power in the process? This holds the main answer to the key questions of the four previous publications of “Vechorka.”
And one more circumstance that attracted the attention of professional legal scholars: why are the heads and lawyers of the Odesa City Council hiding from the high-profile court case? Why have they never appeared in court sessions?
Roman Stolypin:
“I fully agree with the authors of the article; such official arbitrariness cannot be left without attention.
Alexander:
“It’s a shame to read this, to realize that these are the realities of life: corruption, bribery, kickbacks. I hope the prosecutor’s office will defend our rights. Of course, it’s almost unbelievable, as money solves almost everything in this world… But the prosecutor’s office must defend our rights! We believe!!!”
Elena:
“It’s good that the press is covering the events, as Odesa residents and the people should know what is happening in the city! In general, we need to gather for a picket near the building, organize a protest action, not just on the internet should people know what’s happening. Any Odesa resident who finds out will not remain indifferent! And you judges, you should all be kicked out!”
Odesa resident:
“It is confirmed again and again what judges are like! They should all be kicked out! You should all be ashamed, because you are stealing from your own children and grandchildren. This will not go unpunished! Thank you for drawing attention to us, Odesa residents, we care, we are following the circumstances of the case and are worried. I hope the judicial system will come to its senses.”
Prepared by
Nikolai Rozovaykin. Representative of the International Organization for Human Rights Protection,
member of the National Union of Journalists of Ukraine











