Last Wednesday, a press conference was held at the office of the Odesa regional organization of the National Union of Journalists of Ukraine, during which representatives of the Charitable Organization “Seafarers’ Assistance Fund ‘Assol'” summed up the results of the project “Problems faced by seafarers due to the financial instability of the shipowner or operator (abandoned vessels and crews during a crisis), and ways to prevent them.” The partner of the charitable organization was the International Renaissance Foundation.
As a reminder, the fund has been working on the project since the beginning of this year. And at the end of September, at the initiative of the Charitable Organization “Assol,” a “round table” was held, during which the maritime community of the city discussed the memo prepared by the charitable organization for Ukrainian “under-flag” seafarers with recommendations on how to behave correctly in emergency situations. “Vechernaya Odesa” reported on this in its issues of March 26 and October 1.
— According to official data, over 200,000 of our citizens have seafarer identity documents, — noted the project manager, analyst of the “Assol” fund, Andriy Shevchenko. — It is clear that not all of them work at sea. According to approximate estimates, the number of those actually working is 100-120 thousand citizens. And 99 percent of them are on vessels under so-called “convenient” flags. It is clear that this circumstance creates additional problems when emergency situations suddenly arise, and the crew needs help. But how to do this if the vessel is in a foreign port, it belongs, of course, not to a Ukrainian shipowner, but sails under the flag of, for example, the Cayman Islands? And what should seafarers do? After all, they are in the territory of a foreign state, which has its own laws and rules. But if you are warned in advance about how to behave correctly in unforeseen situations, then you are armed.
— Undoubtedly, such knowledge is needed, first of all, by young seafarers who are just starting their “under-flag” careers, — emphasized the coordinator of the educational part of the project, Halyna Fyut. — The beginning of their working life should not be spoiled. Therefore, within the framework of the project, special attention was paid to the educational direction. We gave lectures to cadets of higher and secondary maritime educational institutions in Odesa, Mykolaiv, and Kherson. Future seafarers asked a lot of questions, and we answered them. At the end of October, we will visit these educational institutions again and bring the memo. We decided to distribute 70 percent of the print run of this, figuratively speaking, instruction on the algorithm of behavior in emergency situations to those who are just going to sea.
— The preparation of the memo was preceded by work on analyzing current legislation and studying the activities of intermediary enterprises providing employment services for citizens on vessels of foreign shipowners, — continues the project lawyer Maksym Kocherzhenko. — Unfortunately, the violation of seafarers’ rights often begins on shore. Thus, according to the Law of Ukraine “On Employment of the Population,” which came into force on January 1 of this year, the intermediary is responsible for the deterioration of the terms of the employment contract (agreement) concluded by an employee with a foreign employer. However, the legislator has not specified what kind of responsibility this is — administrative, financial, criminal, or how to implement it in practice. The only positive effect of this legislative innovation is the requirement for the intermediary to keep copies of the aforementioned employment contracts (agreements) for three years.
Among the violations that intermediary enterprises commit in their work, Maksym Kocherzhenko named the main ones that can later “backfire” when a seafarer gets into an unforeseen situation. This is the failure to provide an “under-flag” seafarer, who is about to embark on a voyage, with a copy of the collective agreement concluded between the Ukrainian maritime trade union and the foreign shipowner. That is, the seafarer does not know exactly how his rights will be protected in case of force majeure circumstances, and what troubles he is insured against.
It happens that the intermediary does not inform the person to whom they provided employment services under a “flag” about which vessel they will work on, what the name of the shipowning company is, and what nationality the crew members are. It happens that a crewing company — without the seafarer’s consent — makes their personal data public by posting it on the internet. Well, and bribery for help in employment remains an ineradicable phenomenon so far.
However, as noted by the project manager Andriy Shevchenko, seafarers often abet the aforementioned violations of the law, turning a blind eye to them. The situation in the maritime labor market today is such that there is not much choice. There are practically no merchant ships under the Ukrainian flag left. And on the world fleet, competition has intensified so much that work — if we are talking about Ukrainian maritime specialists — is guaranteed only to experienced senior officers with excellent knowledge of English who have worked without remarks in the same company for several contracts. All other categories of workers, especially ratings, have to fight for their jobs. And often this fight is without rules…
Should we then be surprised that when the Charitable Organization “Assol” begins to collect information about another vessel abandoned by a foreign shipowner, the question suddenly arises: how did the Ukrainian seafarers, members of the crew of the “forgotten” steamer, even go on a voyage? The crewing company is “illegal” because it operates without a license, the foreign shipowner is a phantom because it is unclear where to find them, and there is no employment contract (agreement) and never was.
However, as A. Shevchenko noted, life itself suggests the need to continue working on the project — even after its completion. Since the beginning of this year, the charitable organization has helped Ukrainian crews from 16 abandoned vessels. 174 seafarers received wages that foreign shipowners, for some reason, did not want to pay. However, seafarers from thirteen more “under-flag” vessels are now awaiting assistance. The Charitable Organization “Assol” is actively working with them, developing an algorithm for correctly exiting force majeure situations. So, how can we close the project under such conditions?











