By its decision of December 22, 2010, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine prohibited traffic police inspectors from fining traffic rule violators for speeding based on data recorded by special technical devices operating in automatic mode, without drawing up an administrative offense report.
We remind you that in connection with the adoption of the Law of Ukraine “On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine on Improving the Regulation of Relations in the Field of Road Traffic Safety” dated September 24, 2008, No. 586-VI, the Code of Administrative Offenses (CAO) was supplemented with Article 141 “Responsibility of Owners (Co-owners) of Vehicles” and Part 6 of Article 258 “Cases when an administrative offense report is not drawn up.”
Thus, Part 6 of Article 258 of the CAO stipulated that in case of detection of an administrative offense in the field of road traffic safety, recorded using special technical devices operating in automatic mode, which have photo and film recording, video recording functions, or photo and film recording, video recording devices, an administrative offense report is not drawn up, and a decision on the administrative offense case is made without the participation of the person being brought to administrative responsibility. A copy of the decision on the case was sent to the person being brought to administrative responsibility within three days from the date of such decision.
Thus, traffic police inspectors were granted the right to fine drivers based on data recorded by special technical devices operating in automatic mode. And then copies of decisions on administrative offense cases were sent to the owners of vehicles by mail.
In accordance with Article 141 of the CAO, for violations in the field of road traffic safety, in case of their fixation by devices operating in automatic mode, the owners (co-owners) of vehicles were held liable.
The constitutionality of this provision raised doubts on the grounds that Article 141 of the CAO provides for specific features of bringing owners (co-owners) of vehicles to responsibility, but does not define the composition of the offense, which can only be considered in systemic connection with other articles provided for by the special part of the CAO.
In addition, in accordance with Art. 2, 318 of the Civil Code of Ukraine, the owner of a vehicle can be either an individual or a legal entity. In this case, the question arises: can a legal entity be held liable for an administrative offense in the field of road traffic safety? This question can be answered by referring to Article 61 of the Constitution of Ukraine, which states that legal responsibility is individual in nature, as well as to the decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine of May 30, 2001, No. 7-rp/2001 (case on the responsibility of third parties), from which it can be concluded that only individuals can be brought to administrative responsibility for such offenses.
Thus, the aforementioned provisions of the CAO were declared unconstitutional and lost their force from the date of the decision of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, i.e., from December 22, 2010.
Now traffic police inspectors are prohibited from fining drivers without drawing up an administrative offense report based on data recorded by special technical devices operating in automatic mode. And bringing owners (co-owners) of vehicles to responsibility in the absence of their guilt is illegal.
The Constitutional Court of Ukraine also recommended that the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine bring the procedure for bringing to administrative responsibility for traffic violations recorded by special technical means operating in automatic mode into compliance.











